Showing posts with label third-runway noise; noise mitigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label third-runway noise; noise mitigation. Show all posts

23 June 2010

Sea-Tac Part 150 study behind schedule

The following statement on the Sea-Tac Part 150 noise study has been submitted to the Port Commission by RCAA.

The Part 150 noise study has fallen far behind the published schedule.  Public-participation is suffering as a result.  We fear that the consultants will make major decisions outside of public view, in order to catch up. 

Let’s review:  In order to do meaningful noises reduction, you have to understand where the noise comes from.  That requires that you have good data on certain key elements --

            *  the fleet mix &

            *  flight operations, present & future

In order to predict future flight operations in detail, you need to know how the various runways will be used:  you need a runway-usage plan.  You also need aviation forecasts, estimates of future travel for the whole airport. 

From all of this information, you can prepare noise exposure maps to tell you where noise is being experienced, & you can then propose methods to reduce the noise.  And the point of this exercise is to reduce the noise.  Reduction is cheaper than mitigation.  

Aviation forecasts for the Airport were scheduled for completion in early May, but so far the consultants have released no information about that key element.  

Nothing in the way of a runway usage plan has even been discussed with the public.  It is true that in the end the actual runway usage plan will come from the FAA, but the consultants cannot wait for the FAA to make a proposal.  In a Part 150 study, proposals come from the airport operator (that’s the Commission), & the airport operator hires a consultant to make proposals.  

Noise-exposure maps as of the present are due out next month.  The public does not know what will be mapped or how.  

The schedule calls for the consultants to produce their analysis of future noise exposure in September.  This work will apparently be completed before the next opportunity for public input, which is the workshop planned for October. 

No runway-usage plan, no traffic forecasts, & no current noise data.  All these key elements are to be dealt with in the Summer and Fall, with no public involvement, to be followed by publication of maps of future noise exposure, again with no public involvement till after the decisions are made. 

If you have the key elements, you can know where the noise is.  If you develop the data for these key elements with no significant public involvement, then you do not have meaningful public participation, no matter how many workshops are held, no matter how many slides there are in your Powerpoint presentations.  And as you move to the stage of proposing noise remedies, you will NOT have consensus on the underlying data.  And you will not have much public acceptance of the final results of the study. 

 


25 February 2010

Good Work !

Congratulations to those who attended last night's kick-off workshop for Sea-Tac Airport's Part 150 study!  Despite a restrictive format, the public delivered a loud & clear message spelling out major issues that concern us all.  

After an initial presentation, the attendees (estimated at about 200) crowded around the whiteboards in 15 break-out groups.   We heard over & over that the attendees do not believe that the FAA's 65 DNL noise assessment has anything to do with noise as it is actually experienced.  We heard over & over that single-event noise --not averages -- is what intrudes on people's lives.   Sharp questions were raised about the five-year planning horizon:  the study needs to look long-term.  And what will the Airport look like, what will it sound like, at its maximum?  At the concluding, wrap-up session, there was widespread spontaneous applause for comments that the region needs two more airports, & for the suggestion that if the present noise cannot be fixed, the airport should be moved.  Less-controversial comments included pleas for more noise insulation, more buy-outs, more sellers' assistance programs.


08 January 2010

Sea-Tac plows ahead with Part 150 study

The Port of Seattle announced today that a contract had been signed with the aviation consultancy Landrum & Brown, to manage the pending Part 150 (noise reduction) study at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport.   The Port's news release appears below.

The contract was negotiated privately with the consultant, without input from the communities and local governments who suffer harm from the Airport's noise.   We have not yet seen the actual contract, but the proposed scope of work for that contract, as we have seen it in the last couple of weeks, fails to address about two-thirds of what can & should be done in a study like this.  RCAA's request for disclosure of the actual contract is pending with the Port.  More on this as soon as we have solid information.

Text of the news release

The Port of Seattle has finalized its contract with Landrum & Brown, an aviation and airport planning firm, hired to assist the Port with the management of Sea-Tac Airport's Part 150 Study. Learn more about the Part 150 Scope of Work (103 KB, PDF - http://www.portseattle.org/downloads/community/environment/Part150-scopeofwork.pdf) which includes the project schedule and a detailed description of the work items required for completion of the study.
 
The date and the location of the first public workshop, open to all, will be announced soon.


13 October 2009

Noise is where you hear it

Here's a link to a news story in a Seattle neighborhood blog about a recent Sea-Tac noise meeting in the central part of Seattle.  It's NOT just some folks who "moved down by the Airport" who are affected.

The comments on the blog's story are instructive.  The underlying thought beneath such comments appears to be, "The end always justifies the means, however destructive, however unnecessary, the means are."  

If the link fails, try pasting the URL into your browser in the good old-fashioned manner --

http://www.centraldistrictnews.com/2009/10/12/airplane-noise-no-changes-any-time-soon

24 September 2009

Keep your eye on the FAA

The noise meeting on the 29th is not so far in the future.  As folks think about questions that should be asked, it would be good to keep in mind that this new unexpected noise from the third runway is now entirely the responsibility of the Federal Aviation Administration.  The Port of Seattle's noise program cannot re-direct the airplanes, cannot create a curfew, cannot mandate changes in flight procedures ... 

Here's more on this topic, the text of a letter to the Highline Times that was published last January but which is still right on point.

= = < > = =

The Regional Commission on Airport Affairs finds it unacceptable that the Federal Aviation Administration is operating the third runway at Sea-Tac Airport in disregard of the many assurances given to the public that the runway would almost exclusively for arrivals in poor weather, rather than for arrivals and departures during good weather.


The FAA needs to work with the Port of Seattle to bring use of the runway into line with the plans that were announced to the public in 1996 and 1997. The runway project went through several levels of administrative and court review, always with the understanding that noise from the runway would be quite limited because of its limited use. That was the FAA's position publicly. It's much too late for the FAA go back on its word.

The FAA, and only the FAA, controls how runways are used. So the FAA cannot sit back and expect the Port of Seattle to deal with the problem. This is an FAA-created problem.

The FAA needs to renew its commitments to the Port, the airlines, & the public that the runway would be operated for dealing with bad-weather arrival delay, & not as a full-time all weather airstrip. And the FAA needs to take the lead in keeping the public informed with solid, reliable statistics about third-runway use.

The FAA is a public agency. It needs to take public responsibility for its actions. It needs to keep faith with the public. 

/s/  Lawrence J. Corvari, President

10 September 2009

community noise meeting on 29 September

A second community meeting on Sea-Tac noise has been scheduled for Tuesday, 29 September, from 7 to 9 p.m., at the State Criminal Justice Training Commission Auditorium: 19010—1st Ave S, Burien, according to an announcement from Rep. Dave Upthegrove (D-33).

Text of the announcement follows:

Dear Neighbors,
 
As you know, our August 19th Community Meeting on Airport Noise was attended by more people than the venue could accommodate. I know that many of you took time away from your families and other duties to attend this meeting and I apologize to everyone who was turned away. Please know that simply by showing up, you helped to demonstrate just how deeply this issue affects our community.
 
We have scheduled a follow-up meeting to accommodate those who were turned away last month. Please join me, along with Senator Karen Keiser, Representative Tina Orwall, Des Moines City Councilwoman Susan White, and King County Councilmember Julia Patterson, to discuss airport flight operations and noise mitigation programs. 
 
While the state legislature and county and city governments have no direct authority over SeaTac Airport flight operations (where and when planes fly), we have heard from many of you with questions and concerns about increased noise since the third runway has gone into use. This meeting will be an opportunity to hear directly from the Noise Programs Manager at SeaTac Airport and to ask questions and share information and concerns.
 
Some of the questions to be addressed:
Who decides who gets money for noise insulation?
Who is responsible for determining runway usage and flight patterns?
How does current use of the Third Runway compare with previous projections?
How has airplane noise changed in the last decade?
How can community members monitor and track runway usage and flight operations?
 
Noise from airport operations significantly impacts our quality of life. The more informed we are about how flight decisions are made and how noise mitigation funding decisions are made, then the more effective we all can be advocating for the interests of our community.
 
Sincerely,
 
Dave Upthegrove
State Representative
33rd District