A comment on the Part 150 noise study at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport
The work of the Part 150 noise-study team is almost over. The basic contents of the final report are already available in the study team’s presentation on 29 July to the so-called Technical Review Committee. (Available at the special website for the study.) Even a casual look at slide 32 in that presentation will show how very little is being proposed for noise relief or noise mitigation. This is not much result for a study that will cost more than a million dollars.
The really interesting part of this process is the "flim-flam" that has gone on. As any good magician knows, success comes by getting the audience looking one way while he is working in the other direction.
Almost all of the public meetings/process were directed at the way the Part 150 study was being conducted. While this was going on, the study consultants, Landrum & Brown, were working outside of the public view or review on the actual subjects of the study.
In July they published the "2009 noise contour maps", the "Aviation planning forecast", and the outline of the "Noise Compatibility Plan". These are the required basics of a Part 150 process.
A Part 150 study is supposed to look at NOISE REDUCTION, NOISE MITIGATION, and LAND USE PLANNING. The noise-study team have successfully completed a Part 150 study without touching any of these topics.
16 September 2010
Flim-Flam Artists at Work
20 August 2010
Will Port spend own money for noise relief?
Does the Port of Seattle have $73 million in Airport money that could be used for noise relief?
When dealing with the Port of Seattle about Airport-related noise, the Port's consistent message has been that it will not, cannot, or is not allowed to spend its own money. We recall former Commissioner Paige Miller insisting (for years) that no Port money could be used to help with the noise in the buildings of the Highline School District. FAA money or nothing. In the end, the Port agreed to provide $50 million for school insulation & rebuilding from tax revenues.
There is, of course, no general legal barrier to the Port District spending its own money (tax revenue, net profits from its various lines of business) for such things as property buy-outs, insulation of noise-affected homes & schools, investment in real estate, buying abandoned railway right-of-way, helping to fund a new South Park bridge, &c. There are some restrictions on use of money from direct operation of the Airport. But it is our understanding that what are called "non-aero" profits are free of FAA-imposed constraints (as are general revenue from property taxes).
So the "Miller Doctrine" (FAA money or nothing) was not based on legalities. Maybe it was nothing but stinginess.
A staff briefing to the Port Commission on 17 August revealed that the Airport expects to make net operating income (profits) on "non-aero" business of $73 million this year (2010). The Port District needs to be very clear & straightforward with the community about how this money can be used. If it is legally not available for noise relief, let's see an understandable explanation (not the "Miller Doctrine" re-stated). Otherwise, the study team for the Part 150 noise study, & the interested public should feel free to make recommendations for noise relief actually paid for by the Port.
+ + +
The staff briefing (in 36 Powerpoint slides) can be downloaded from the Port's website. The "non-aero NOI" is discussed on Slide 8. Go to
http://www.portseattle.org/about/organization/commission/meetingagenda.shtml
Then click on the agenda for 17 August, & then find agenda item 7 b & click on PowerPoint. That will give you the slideshow.
II-010-008-D
19 July 2010
Noise-measurement workshop, 29 July
Landrum & Brown, lead consultants for the noise study at Sea-Tac Airport, have announced that a "Technical Noise Workshop", featuring Vince Mestre, PE, will be held on Thursday, 29 July at the Beijing Room in the main terminal at the Airport, from 12.30 to 1.30 pm..
After the formal session of the 9 June noise-study workshop, Mr Mestre met briefly with some of the attendees (including Normandy Park Mayor George Hadley & Burien Councilwoman Rose Clark), to discuss in more depth the noise-modelling & noise-measurement issues that are involved in the study. This unplanned seminar (if we may call it that) was so informative that Clark & Hadley immediately suggested that Mr Mestre come back to the area for an extended discussion of these issues for the benefit of people interested in the technical details. Although the request was for an evening meeting on a Wednesday (to accommodate city electeds & senior staff), the study team has chosen a shorter session in the middle of the work day.
Mayor Hadley has circulated a group of questions that he would like to see addressed -- too extensive for a 'blog' post. Contact RCAA or Mayor Hadley for a copy.
28 April 2010
Another Sea-Tac runway closure
Local readers will have received the current (print) issue of the Highline Times, with its front-page story about the planned closure of the center runway at Sea-Tac Airport for two month (July & August) for some temporary repairs. Folks who do not see the Times can view this article on the paper's website. If the link doesn't work, here's the URL: http://www.highlinetimes.com/2010/04/22/news/third-runway-be-noisier-again-summer-second-runway-closed-repairs
The project bears an estimated cost of $5,650,000 -- we have more to say about that later in this post
This project caught the interested public by complete surprise. Neither the Times nor RCAA picked up this story when the Seattle Port Commission had the project on its agenda for 9 February. Oddly, the super-active PR office at the Port did not issue a press release on this interesting topic. (Critics will say that we shouldn't wait for the PR folks to serve up stories on silver salvers, & the critics will be right.)
The urgency of the project is not apparent, given that Airport staff have plans to rebuild the whole runway, stem to stern, in the relatively near future (2016). But safety concerns have been expressed, which tend to override all other considerations. A staff memo. describes the work as replacement of about 150 concrete panels. The runway has already been given a quick fix by way of re-sealing joints between panels (2008). As one has come to expect, no environmental assessment has been published for the current project.
Now about the cost:
First point -- The new budget of $5,650,00 is an increase of 146 percent over the 2008 estimate ($2,415,000). Sounds like a mini-micro version of the project creep (leap?) for the third runway. No engineering documents were submitted to the Commission to explain this increase, & we have no explanation to offer.
Second point: The actual construction costs are estimated at $4 million. Add some outside consultants' work & the sales tax ($485,000). What's left is $1,165,000 for administrative costs (Port staff, that is). One has to wonder, what's to administer? Folks with real-world business experience are invited to tell us whether this is a sensible cost, or whether it's gold-plated feather-bedding.
A final point: The construction staff state that having the runway closed for two months will not affect the pending Part 150 noise study, because "the noise contours will be based off of 2009 operations and fleet mix when all runways were operational". We wonder if the noise-study team agrees.
II-010-008D
II-010-052 (b)
24 March 2010
Port Commission DOES hear from public
The meeting of the Port Commission on Tuesday, 23 March, indeed did hear from the public on the subject of the Part 150 noise study now underway for Sea-Tac Airport. Our post on the 19th reflected uncertainty on this point. As part of its regular business meeting the Commission had scheduled a staff briefing on the study, but no action was contemplated. Nonetheless, a small group of interested members of the public, as well as local elected officials, were on hand.
The staff presentation was held to a minimum. Commissioners had available print versions of the extensive report on the 24 February 2010 workshop. It was not clear whether they had found time to peruse it, & there was minimal discussion between the Commission & staff.
The bulk of the comments seemed to deal with issues that the study team had not come to grips with.
* For example, Pastor Jon Cortese, Burien Free Methodist Church, pointed out that many churches are subject to overflight noise, yet the study team was not suggesting anything that dealt with their problems.
* Clarke Brant, Normandy Park Councilmember, responding to a comment from the Airport's noise-program manager, Stan Shepherd, that a night-time curfew was outside the scope of the study, noted that most developed countries do not allow night-time operations at metropolitan airports. He called upon the Commission to advocate changes in Federal law to return control of night-time flights to local authorities.
* Shawn McEvoy, Councilmember from Normandy Park (& former mayor), urged the Commission to fund mitigation outside the 65 DNL contour. Mr McEvoy also spoke to the need for the study to have a longer planning horizon (at least 10 years), the need to define noise from the third runway with care, & the need to examine compliance with existing procedures.
We will carry on this discussion in later posts.
Next Part 150 workshop -- 9 June
The next public workshop in Sea-Tac Airport's Part 150 noise study has been scheduled for 6.30 p.m., Wednesday, 9 June, at Cedarhurst Elementary School in Burien, according to an announcement made at the meeting of the Port Commission on 23 March. An agenda for the workshop has not been released at this time.
Cedarhurst Elementary School is located at
19 March 2010
Port Commission may hear from the public
Public comment on the pending Part 150 study may be allowed -- or perhaps not -- at the meeting of the Seattle Port Commission on Tuesday, 23 March, at The Cove in Normandy Park. A staff briefing on the study is shown on the agenda as Item 7 a. Under the Commission's rules of procedure, "The Commission does not generally take public testimony for non-action agenda items such as "Staff Briefings," but may do so at the discretion of the Commission Chair". We have not seen anything that officially says that Commission President Bill Bryant will allow public comment -- if it is allowed, commenters must sign up before the presentation begins.
The meeting is scheduled to begin at 12 noon, with Item 7 a noted as beginning at 1 p.m. (suggesting that whoever writes these agendas is expecting unusual public interest in this item).
Acoustics at The Cove are lousy -- fine for dance bands but not for public meetings. Perhaps Port staff will provide extra microphones & a better sound system -- we'll ask.
Report on Part 150 workshop, 24 Feb.
An extensive report on the Part 150 workshop held on 24 February has been posted on the special Part 150 website. For those who were unable to attend on the 24th, this report will provide some of the flavor. The over-all summary prepared by the consultants suffers from a certain amount of 'spin' (who's surprised?), but the summaries from the 15 break-out sessions are closer to the reality. The actual worksheets prepared by the 15 facilitators are even closer to the reality, while the hand-written comments submitted by a few participants deserve extra attention.
Readers who attended the workshop & are now thinking about attending the Port Commission's meeting on the 23rd in order to comment (see next posting) may want to refresh their memories as to what was said a month ago.
The report is a whopper -- over 6 megabytes, & all in one file. As RCAA suggested to the consultants a month ago, it's better to do these big "posts" in segments, so that the user can download (more quickly) just what he or she is interested in.